The Reincarnation of Peter Proud (1975)

College Professor Peter Proud (Michael Sarrazin) has a recurring dream about a man swimming on a lake late at night. A woman named Marcia (Margot Kidder) paddles a small boat out to meet him. As the man tries to climb aboard, Marcia hits him with an oar and he drowns. Perplexed and disturbed, Peter approaches Doctor Sam Goodman (Paul Hecht) who is conducting research into sleep at the College. He conducts several tests which prove that Peter’s experiences are not registering as dreams. The Doctor suggests that they’re hallucinations but Peter theorises that they may be memories of a past life. A chance viewing of a TV documentary about Massachusetts, triggers further memories, so Peter decides to go an investigate. He subsequently learns that the man in his visions is a former Tennis coach, Jeff Curtis, who died in the late 1940s under mysterious circumstances. Is Peter the reincarnation of this man? If so, didn’t he have a daughter, Ann (Jennifer O’Neil). Furthermore is Marcia, Ann’s mother, still alive?

One of the most noticeable changes that has occurred in mainstream cinema over the last 130 years, is the narrative pace, more simply known as pacing. Contemporary cinema can be somewhat hectic. In the case of The Reincarnation of Peter Proud, the direction by veteran film maker J. Lee Thompson, is deliberately languid. The story itself could have been an episode of the Twilight Zone. Yet the slow pacing and enigmatic unfolding of the story creates a somewhat dream like atmosphere which suits the film. The screenplay by Max Ehrlich, who adapted his own novel, leans heavily into the sexual culture and social morality of the mid-seventies and offers an interesting snapshot of liberal middle-class culture of that decade. It is also interesting to see how scientific community at the time was not unequivocally opposed to exploring the paranormal. Doctor Goodman is not immediately dismissive of Peter’s theories and encourages him to explore them.

There is a great score by Jerry Goldsmith which mixes his traditional up beat, light orchestral style from that time with various discordant electronic cues. The latter underpin the potentially supernatural plot elements and certainly give the story an off kilter atmosphere. Overall, The Reincarnation of Peter Proud is a film that focuses upon creating a mood and its enjoyment lies very much in the narrative journey. It is a tale of self discovery, tempered with a sense of inevitability. It does have some flaws, such as Margot Kidder’s age make-up and a plot that has unpleasant implications if you think too much about them. However, despite the laissez faire attitude of both Peter Proud and his former self, toward sexual encounters, there is a distinctly moral tone to the story’s resolution. In many respects it’s reminiscent of M. R. James and his established tropes of knowing when to “stop sticking your nose in” and academics who are the architects of their own demise.

Roger Edwards
Writer & editor of Contains Moderate Peril. A website about gaming, genre movies & cult TV. Co-host of the Burton & Scrooge podcast.
http://containsmoderateperil.com
Next
Next

Video Games and Character Creation