El Orfanato AKA The Orphanage (2007)
Laura García Rodríguez is adopted from an orphanage as a child. 30 years later, adult Laura (Belén Rueda) returns to the now closed orphanage, accompanied by her husband, Dr. Carlos Sánchez Rivera (Fernando Cayo), and their seven-year-old son, Simón (Roger Príncep). They plan to use the orphanage as a facility for disabled children. In the meantime, Simón talks about a boy named Tomás. He draws pictures of his new friend as a child wearing a sack mask. A social worker, Benigna Escobedo (Montserrat Carulla), visits Simón, as he has been adopted by Laura and Carlos. Simón is HIV positive. Angered by Benigna's unscheduled visit, Laura asks her to leave. She later finds Benigna in the orphanage's coal shed, but Benigna gets away. Simón becomes more enamoured with his imaginary friends but becomes angry when he learns from Tomás that Laura is not his birth mother, and he is terminally ill.
El Orfanato includes many of the classic hallmarks of supernatural cinema. There is a suitably gothic building, near to a beach. The cliff has secret caves that flood at high tide. Then there are the ghosts themselves who remain hidden for much of the film. Director J. A. Bayona uses sound and sleight of hand to build the atmosphere. There are a few shocks, that although not excessively graphic, are jolting due to their skillful execution. Children are represented honestly and credibly, and the story does not shy away from showing both their inclusionary and exclusionary proclivities. Too many US films depict children in a saintly manner, especially when a dying child is used as a plot device. Both Belén Rueda and Fernando Cayo excel as parent’s dealing with an impossible situation. Again, the emotional strain upon their relationship is shown realistically.
Screenwriter Sergio Sánchez touches on several classic themes that frequently occur within the horror genre. The stigma of deformity and of difference, as well as the cruelty of children. This is depicted both in the way Simón is treated when others find out about his illness and in a subplot regarding his ghostly friend Tomás. The story also deals with regret, guilt and a mother’s love. However, all of which is handled in an intelligent, nuanced and remarkable unsentimental manner. Instead, we are present with genuine tragedy, pathos and melancholy. Despite such bleak subject’s cinematographer Óscar Faura imbues the proceedings with great beauty. The conclusion is quite radical and not what you would call a “Hollywood ending”. Yet it is an emotionally honest outcome. El Orfanato is a fine example of “kinder horror” and an exceedingly well-crafted film that conspicuously avoids the contrived sensibilities of US cinema. It is an emotionally raw and moving film but also a very rewarding one.